Creationism, Materialism, Piety and Arrogance

In a previous post, I wrote a bit about my opinions on human arrogance (An Arrogant Bent).  I was generally referring to any person who feels a sense of superiority and self-importance over others, which many of us may have exhibited traits of at one time or another.

There is so much in the universe that cannot be explained due to a lack of empirical evidence.  There is no physical evidence that proves how our universe came into being (or any other universe, for that matter, if you believe in multi-verse theory), nor is there any material evidence of exactly how and when human life on earth came into being, either.

Materialists and creationists have debated their viewpoints on this for quite some time.  Both sides of the debate have provided thoughtful reason behind their beliefs on what are essentially unknown and unobservable events.

So, from a purely physical and material perspective, I believe that creationism and materialism are on equal footing here since neither side can provide empirical evidence to support their position.  For the creationist, the foundation is the belief that everything in existence is the product of an omnipotent, omniscient and eternal creator.  For materialists, the foundation is the belief that everything in existence is due to natural causes.

What concerns me is how people approach one another on these issues.  I would prefer that people always treat one another with respect and dignity when dialog occurs on this (really, any topic, of course), but that doesn’t always seem to be the case.  There are some creationists who sometimes react in a rigidly pious manner (holier than thou);  likewise, there are some materialists who sometimes react in a vain and arrogant manner (smarter than thou).

Have either of these reactions seemed common to you?  If so, do you find it difficult to resist responding in like manner when your beliefs are in question?  The reason this is of concern to me is that I believe that both behaviors diminish the understanding between opposing viewpoints.  My further concern is with how this affects our youth, both in high school and especially in college where young minds are so vulnerable when hearing only one side of any debate.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in atheism, Biology, Christianity, Cosmology, Creation, Faith, Humanity, Materialism, Science and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Creationism, Materialism, Piety and Arrogance

  1. “I would prefer that people always treat one another with respect and dignity when dialog occurs on this (really, any topic, of course), but that doesn’t always seem to be the case.”

    Can I ask you, do you treat holocause deniers, racists,sexists, etc with “respect and dignity” when they make their claims?

    And do you treat the universe as if the materialists are right or the theists? Do you expect the impossible or do you trust that the laws of physics work and won’t change?

    Like

  2. Doyle says:

    I do not respect nor would I dignify a racist or sexist, and I do not deny that the Holocaust occurred. I was speaking specifically on the topic of this post. I did say “really, any topic” – but I didn’t mean that I would offer respect and dignity to people who support inhumane ideals. My mistake.

    I think that many times theists and materialists are both correct, sometimes they are not. I do not believe that science and creationism are mutually exclusive. Yes, I do trust that the laws of physics work and won’t change. Science recognizes many attributes of the universe that are immutable. I believe that these immutable universal laws require a lawgiver, and that these laws could not have defined themselves.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s